Winter Survival of Alfalfa

 

Introduction
Manitoba’s long, cold winters pose a significant risk of winter kill and winter injury in alfalfa stands. While winter kill causes immediate yield loss, winter injury reduces productivity over time as damaged plants recover slowly and stands thin out. Every management decision from spring thaw to freeze-up affects winter survival. Proper planning protects yield potential and stand persistence.

 
Key Factors for Winter Survival
1. Variety Selection
  • Choose varieties with fall dormancy ratings of 1–3 for better winter survival.
    • The better fall dormancy rating a variety has, the earlier the variety goes dormant in the fall, limiting total productivity
  • Higher dormancy ratings (4) offer more productivity but require careful management.
  • Refer to the Manitoba Seed Guide for fall dormancy and winter hardiness ratings.
  • Select varieties with strong disease resistance (bacterial wilt, verticillium wilt, phytophthora root rot).
 
2. Stand Age and Health
  • Older stands (3+ years) face higher winter kill risk due to:
    • Increased disease pressure
    • Reduced fertility
    • Excessive past cuttings
  • Wheel traffic damage - Research shows traffic five days after cutting significantly reduces subsequent yields compared to two days.\Young stands generally survive better due to higher density and plant health.
  • Avoid late-season cutting without adequate regrowth before freeze-up.
  • Provide sufficient recovery time to replenish root reserves.

3. Fertility – Key Nutrients for Alfalfa

Even the most winter-hardy alfalfa variety can fail without proper nutrition. Nutrient deficiencies increase susceptibility to disease, slow regrowth, reduce yield, and shorten stand life. Balanced fertility is essential for maximizing productivity and ensuring winter survival.
Phosphorus (P)
  • Critical for root development, disease resistance, maturity, and nitrogen fixation.
  • Supports overall plant health and stand persistence.
Potassium (K)
  • Essential for growth and winter hardiness.
  • Acts as a natural antifreeze, accumulating in plant cells during fall to protect against freezing.
  • High-yielding alfalfa removes up to 45 lb of K per tonne of forage.
  • Manitoba soils are generally high in K, but sandy soils and side slopes often require supplementation.

 
Fertility Recommendations
  • Soil Testing: Regular testing ensures adequate nutrient levels for alfalfa’s high demands.
  • Potassium Application: Apply in fall on low-K soils, especially before establishing new stands.
  • Phosphorus Application: Maintain sufficient levels for strong root systems and disease resistance.
  • Avoid nitrogen fertilization—alfalfa fixes its own nitrogen.

 
Why Fertility Matters
  • Prevents winter kill and injury.
  • Maximizes annual yields and stand longevity.
  • Reduces weed pressure.
  • Improves overall plant health and resilience.
7.  Harvest Timing - Key Principles:
a. Cutting Interval
  • After cutting, alfalfa relies on root reserves for regrowth.
  • Reserves are lowest 2–3 weeks post-cut; replenishment begins once sufficient leaf area develops.
  • Recommended interval: 4–5 weeks between cuts, allowing root reserves to recover (typically at ~10% bloom).
  • Cutting too early or too frequently depletes reserves, reducing stand longevity.
b. Critical Fall Harvest Period
  • Alfalfa needs 450–500 growing degree days between the last cut and freeze-up to restore root reserves.
  • In Manitoba, this period spans roughly six weeks before the first killing frost:
    • Northwestern Manitoba: Aug 15
    • Red River Valley: begins Aug. 17–19
    • South-central Manitoba: begins Aug. 23
  • Avoid cutting during this period unless harvesting after a killing frost. Alfalfa is a perennial and constantly respiring and using stored energy even during the winter months. 
As days shorten, alfalfa shifts its energy flow downward, storing carbohydrates in the roots to survive winter and fuel spring regrowth. Cutting too late in the season disrupts this process. When root reserves are depleted for regrowth, there are not enough growing degree days left to replenish them before freeze-up. These plants enter winter weakened, making them highly susceptible to winter kill and winter injury, and they often struggle to regrow in spring.
  • Root Reserve Dynamics
    • After cutting, plants use root reserves for regrowth.
    • Reserves are lowest at 6–8 inches of regrowth and fully replenished at full bloom.
    • If frost occurs before reserves recover, winter injury is likely.
 
 
c. Late-Season Cutting
  • Cutting too late without regrowth risks severe winter kill.
  • If taking a final cut:
    • Wait until a killing frost (approx. -5°C) for minimal impact.
    • Consider baled silage for faster dry-down.
  • Allowing one cut to reach 50% bloom, especially the last cut, improves winter survival by maximizing root reserves.
  • Leave strips of uncut alfalfa every 40-50 feet to trap snow and insulate crowns

 
Management Tips
  • Use PEAQ (Predictive Equation for Alfalfa Quality) to optimize harvest timing.
  • Balance economics with stand longevity—one poorly timed cut can reduce next year’s yield.
  • Avoid wheel traffic immediately after cutting; research shows traffic five days post-cut significantly reduces yield compared to two days.
Key Considerations for Winter Survival
1. Snow Cover and Stubble
  • Ideal snow cover: At least 4 inches to insulate soil and protect roots.
  • Leave 6–10 inches of stubble after the last cut to trap snow.
  • Alternating cut and uncut rows can help trap snow but may expose cut rows to injury.
2. Critical Fall Harvest Period
  • Begins approximately six weeks before the first killing frost (450 Growing Degree Days) (varies by region).
  • Avoid cutting during this period to allow plants to:
    • Accumulate root reserves.
    • Enter dormancy gradually.
  • Cutting too late depletes reserves, increasing winter kill risk.
3. Dormancy and Temperature
  • Alfalfa can survive soil temperatures down to -12°C if fully dormant.
  • Warm spells (10°C for 3–4 days) can break dormancy, causing plants to use stored energy.
  • Snow cover helps buffer temperature fluctuations and prevent dormancy breaks.
4. Moisture and Frost Heaving
  • Excess soil moisture can lead to ice sheets or frost heaving, exposing crowns and breaking roots.
  • Clay soils are most susceptible.
  • Avoid early wheel traffic on weakened or frost-heaved plants to prevent further damage.
Identifying Winter Injury in Alfalfa Stands - Why It Matters
Winter injury can be as damaging as winter kill, but its effects appear gradually. Injured plants may green up in spring, then die within weeks, reducing yield and stand persistence throughout the season. Early detection is essential for management decisions.

 
How to Assess Winter Injury
  1. Field Inspection
    • Do not assume a greening field is healthy.
    • Pull or dig several plants for closer examination.
  2. Plant Examination
    • Healthy plants: firm, white roots and crowns.
    • Injured plants: roots appear gray, yellow, or brown, stringy rather than firm.
    • Severely damaged plants often break off just below the soil surface when tugged.
 

 
Monitoring Stand Density
  • Year 1: ~25 plants per square foot.
  • Year 2: Natural thinning to ~12 plants per square foot.
  • Year 3+: Count stems, not plants.
    • Optimal: 40–45 productive stems per square foot.
    • Critical: Fewer than 30–35 stems indicates reduced yield potential and signals stand replacement.

 
Management for Longevity
  • Protect stands from winter injury by:
    • Maintaining balanced fertility.
    • Allowing adequate regrowth between cuttings.
    • Avoiding late-season harvest during the critical fall period.
  • Healthy, pest-free stands with proper rest before freeze-up have the best chance of survival.